Memory Foam Bed Comparisons

Whether you've decided you want a memory foam bed or not, looking at comparison charts can help.

Whether you’ve decided you want a memory foam bed or not, looking at comparison charts can help.

A chart can’t tell you everything, though, and that’s why we read reviews online to find out how others felt about their buying experience – and how the bed really feels. It’s important to remember that loving or hating a bed is such a subjective thing. So, here, we averaged out what reviewers had to say about each of these memory foam beds, which are all considered some of the best memory foam beds out there.

How to Choose the Memory Foam Bed That’s Right for You

There are plenty of features to consider when you’re shopping for a memory foam mattress. You want to make sure it’s comfortable, supportive, and that you can send it back if something goes wrong. Memory foam gets a bad rap for lots of things, such as sleeping hot and sinking in. The good news is that most of the typical memory foam issues have been resolved by most mattress companies, but some do it better than others. So, the best thing you can do to help you pick the right mattress for you is to check out memory foam bed comparisons, such as the one below.

Memory Foam Beds: Let’s Compare

To make it easy to look at the most important specifications for each memory foam mattress, there’s this handy chart. The 1-10 scale is typical: The closer it scores to 1, the softer the bed is, and the closer to 10, the firmer it is. Everything else should be self-explanatory, but there’s a longer description below for each mattress for a more comprehensive look at each one.

Specs The Casper Tuft & Needle Leesa New Purple Fleep Bed
Cost Reasonable Affordable Reasonable Expensive Pricey
Firmness (1-10) 7 6 7 6-7 6, 8
Temperature Neutral Cooler Neutral to warm Cooler Cooler
Coils No No No Yes No
Off-gassing Moderate Minimal High Minimal Moderate
Trial Period 100 100 100 100 111 nights
Warranty 10 10 10 10 10

1. The Casper

The company that ships Casper mattresses to your door was one of the pioneers to change how you shop and buy a mattress today – and this ain’t your momma’s mattress. Casper focuses on providing a firmer surface for back and stomach sleepers, but it also has enough give for side sleepers who need a little more pressure relief for joints at their shoulders and hips. The top layer of foam is designed with open cells to help promote airflow, which means this mattress shouldn’t retain heat. That’s excellent news for any hot sleepers out there who are a bit wary of memory foam. This mattress is made with varying layers of foam to give you the support your body needs. It’s meant to be a happy medium for most people, but if you’re lighter in weight, it may seem too firm. There’s a bit of an off-gassing period, but the odor should dissipate in a day or two of airing out. You get 100 days to try this mattress out, and if you don’t like it, Casper will arrange to have someone pick it up and then it will either be donated or recycled. You’ll get back the full refund, too. If you do keep it, the 10-year warranty means if you see any flaws, such as cracks in the foam that occur beyond normal use, you can get a free repair.

Good for: Hot Sleepers, Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers

Comparable Mattress: Leesa

2. Tuft & Needle

One of the most affordable mattresses in the mattress-in-a-box market is the Tuft & Needle. Perhaps surprisingly, it also has one of the highest satisfaction rates. In addition to the high value of this mattress, owners love its feel. There’s excellent support, but the mattress is rarely considered too firm. The pressure-relief benefits those who sleep on their back, stomach, or side. Although this isn’t a strictly memory foam bed or a latex bed, it acts a bit like both. You get some contouring, but there’s also a bit of bounce. That added bounce means it’s easy to get in and out of bed, and it helps prevent sinking in. There’s little to no edge support, but that might be the biggest issue here. There’s almost no off-gassing of this mattress, and most people said they don’t sleep hot in this bed. The 100-night trial is standard: Don’t like it – send it back; get your money back. The 10-year warranty is also what you’d expect.

Good for: Budget Buy, All Position Sleepers, Hot Sleepers

Comparable Mattress: New Purple Mattress

3. Leesa Mattress

Although the Leesa gets high marks from people who prefer a firm mattress, many people found it to be too firm and needed to add a topper to get some added softness. Back and stomach sleepers may be satisfied with this mattress, though. And it’s reasonably priced for what you’re getting. It’ll take about two weeks to really settle into this mattress, though, so give it some time. There are reports of this mattress sleeping slightly hot, despite the mattress company’s efforts to prevent heat retention. The off-gassing of the Leesa is pervasive and it lasts longer than you’d expect. If you get past that, though, you could experience less back pain and more pressure relief than with your old mattress. You get 100 days to try this mattress out, and if you decide to give it back, so will Leesa – your trialed mattress will be donated or recycled. If you keep your bed and it appears to have a defect, Leesa will repair or replace it – and it’s covered for 10 years.

Good for: Back Sleepers, Average-sized Sleepers

Comparable Mattress: Casper

4. New Purple Mattress

The difference between the New Purple and the Old Purple is, well, a lot. This new version is technically a hybrid mattress now, as it included pocketed coils. Those coils work well toward giving the mattress good edge support, added overall support, and breathability. The patented purple comfort grid is still there, and you get your choice of a 2-, 3-, or 4-inch layer. Of course, the thicker you go, the higher the price goes. And even the 2-inch one is pricey. The benefits may be worth it, though. The New Purple mattress is getting all kinds of kudos from owners who love the new changes – it’s super comfy and there’s almost no off-gassing. It’s especially good for those who were sinking to the support base, as they’re now better supported. You get 100 days to try out the mattress, but Purple wants you to give it at least 30 days before returning it. If you still don’t like it after a month, you’ll get a full refund. The warranty is also as you’d expect: See a defect? The bed will be repaired or replaced in the 10-year period.

Good for: Any Size Sleeper, Any Position Sleeper, Hot Sleepers

Comparable Mattress: Tuft & Needle

5. Fleep Bed

When you just can’t make up your mind between soft and firm, there’s Fleep Bed. One side of the mattress is soft and cushiony for when you want a softer surface. Flip the bed over and you’ll get a firmer bed that offers strong support. The softer side registers at just a little more than a 5, but closer to a 6 on the scale, and the firmer side could feel as firm as an 8. Regardless of which side you choose, the Fleep Bed sleeps cooler, thanks to its cooling materials. You shouldn’t notice too much off-gassing, but it’s a good idea to air it out a couple days after getting the mattress out of its box. This mattress, like others like it, takes a while to adjust to, which is why you get 111 nights to try it out. If you aren’t satisfied, you can arrange to have Fleep pick up your bed for free and get a full refund. Your used mattress will be donated or recycled. If you do keep your Fleep Bed, you get a 10-year warranty that should protect you from any defects in your mattress – just keep your receipt!

Good for: All Position Sleepers, Hot Sleepers

Comparable Mattress: Tuft & Needle

The Bottom Line

All the memory foam mattresses featured above are excellent choices to help you sleep more comfortably. It all comes down to personal preference, though, which is why we’re not picking a winner here. In a way, we’ve picked five winners! If you want the best price, obviously the Tuft & Needle is the best choice for you. If better bounce is what you’re looking for, then the New Purple could be your winner. A firmer choice overall for back and stomach sleepers is the Casper. The Leesa is also a firm-bed lovers’ top pick. And then there’s the Fleep Bed for those who can’t choose between soft and firm, or who like to flip and flop. Whichever one you choose, you’re sure to get a better night’s sleep every night, or you can give it back within 100 (or 111) nights, anyway!

About the author


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.