Find the best crib mattress in 2018. We do all the market research for you, recommending the best crib mattress brands including My First Mattress.

Best Crib Mattress in 2020

Last Updated: April 2020

Editor’s Note

Hi Parents! Thank you for visiting my website. I’ve done my best to provide you with the most in-depth consumer guide with honest and accurate information relating to the best crib mattresses currently on the market. A significant amount of time has been invested in providing you with this information, so I do hope you find it useful.

Most Recommended: If you haven’t got the time to read our entire buyers guide, then I would suggest that you take a look at the My First Mattress – Crib Mattress, a best-selling product.

Click here to view the My First Mattress Crib Mattress

Now I am going to take a logical guess and assume you are here because you are looking for a crib mattress for your baby. Well, you made the smartest decision of the day, as you decided to come to my website. In this best crib mattresssuper-duper buyers guide to the best crib mattresses available I will skip past all the nonsense you tend to see online and only discuss the stuff you really need to know. However, most importantly is that I will also provide you with the best baby crib mattress recommendations based on years of consumer product analysis, this will include various well-known brands such as Sealy, Dream on me, Safety 1st & Kolcraft.

Buying the best crib mattress for your baby may not seem like an exciting task, but it is still an important one. Your little one will spend many, many hours in his or her crib (an average of 18 hours per day), and it is up to you to make the experience as comfortable as possible. For the most part, when looking over which mattress to buy, there are two main things to keep in mind: fit and firmness.

Before we get into the nitty-gritty details of what to look for in a crib mattress I am going to highlight the best-rated crib mattresses available in each category.

Our Best Crib Mattresses of 2020

Owner Rating
5 Star Rating
Made in
Price Check
My First Mattress
8.6 (540+ reviews)
74% Users
Check Price
8.0 (110+ reviews)
67% Users
Check Price
Moonlight Slumber
9.4 (310+ reviews)
84% Users
Check Price
9.0 (460+ reviews)
75% Users
Check Price
8.6 (2,800+ reviews)
67% Users
Check Price

*5 Star Rating: this is based on the percentage of consumers who rate the mattresses 10/10.

Top Rated: My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Crib Mattress
My First Mattress Mattress Premium Memory Foam Crib Mattress

The ‘My First Mattress’ memory foam crib mattress ranks number one on the list for several reasons. Consumers who purchase it rate it highly for many reasons. Unlike mattresses made with other materials, this one is perfectly silent. It makes no noise as your baby moves, allowing him or her to sleep peacefully – and quietly – throughout the night. The extra firm high-density foam provides all of the softness your little one needs to feel comfortable, but it is firm enough to meet safety standards at the same time. It is hypoallergenic, mite-proof, and free of potentially dangerous phthalates found in many other mattresses. It comes with a 100% polyester velour cover that is completely removable and machine washable, and thanks to its squared-off corners, it fits nicely into most toddler bed frames as your little one grows.

Check Price

Warranty & Support9

Visit Retailer

Best Organic: Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Crib Mattress

naturepedic organic crib mattress

For those parents who are concerned about products made from environmentally-friendly and safe materials, the Naturepedic No Compromise organic crib mattress is a no-brainer. It is made with 100% organic cotton and it offers you the two-stage dual firmness that ensures that it can grow with your baby right into toddlerhood. The surface is wipe clean and waterproof, which makes things easier on busy parents and caregivers. The fabric and filling are certified organic, and the mattress contains 150 coils plus edge support to help extend its longevity right through the toddler years. Naturepedic meets the most stringent Greenguard certifications for eliminating chemical emissions, too. If safety and healthy are at the forefront of your mind when shopping for a crib mattress, you cannot go wrong with the Naturepedic No Compromise.

Check Price

Warranty & Support9.5

Visit Retailer

Best Memory Foam & Best Dual Foam: Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer® Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer® Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Dual firmness is an important consideration for many parents. As an infant, your baby needs an extra firm sleeping surface for safety, but as a toddler, a little extra softness can help your little one sleep better throughout the night. The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer dual firmness all foam crib mattress is one of the best buys for the money in the dual firmness category. It is free from dangerous vinyl, polyethylene, phthalates, and PVC, and it comes encased in a durable nylon cover that is waterproof and easy to clean. It offers extra high-density foam on the infant side, but when you flip it over, the toddler side has traditional high-density foam for extra softness. Despite its budget-friendly price, this is still the safest mattress in its class.

Check Price

Warranty & Support9.5

Visit Retailer

Best Natural Foam: Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

If you want to purchase a foam crib mattress for your baby, but you prefer all-natural materials, look no further than the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core mattress. Sealy was the first company in the industry to utilize safe and renewable soybeans to craft a special foam that is firm enough for infants, yet still plush enough for toddlers. The mattress contains no harsh chemicals, including often toxic chemical fire retardants. It comes wrapped in a beautifully embossed cover that protects the inner foam from liquids and allergens. What’s more, the soybean foam is more durable than conventional foam. Parents who dread lifting the mattress to change baby’s sheets will be glad to know that this is one of the lightest crib mattresses on the market, and Sealy offers a lifetime warranty on materials and workmanship.

Check Price

Warranty & Support9.5

Visit Retailer

Best Cheap Crib Mattress: Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Finally, if you are shopping for a budget mattress, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress is always a great choice. It offers you the most features and safety for the price, including a high-density foam core to provide all of the support your precious bundle needs. The sleeping surface is completely lead and phthalate free, and it meets or exceeds federal flammability standards without the use of dangerous chemicals. The cover resists tears, blocks water, and resists odors over time, making it an excellent value dollar-for-dollar.

Check Price

Warranty & Support9

Visit Retailer

The Size of the Crib Mattress

Crib mattress size is important because in order to keep your baby safe, you need to make sure that there are no gaps between the mattress and the crib at the top, the bottom, and both sides. These gaps are potential safety hazards. The federal government actually determines the standard crib mattress size and says that, at a minimum, a crib mattress must be between 27 5/8″ to 28 5/8″ wide & 51 3/4″ to 53″ in length and no thicker than 6”. Today’s cribs are also subject to regulation, but they have a bit of tolerance in order to accommodate mattresses without gaps.

Crib Mattress Firmness

Firmness is also an important consideration when choosing a top rated crib mattress. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that babies sleep on their backs on a firm crib mattress. A soft mattress can actually conform to the baby’s head, as well as his or her face as he or she learns to roll over and cause suffocation or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). A firm mattress, then, is a must-have. Many parents choose innerspring mattresses for this reason, but the truth is that a memory foam crib mattress is just as firm. In fact, memory foam is usually easier to work with and safer as your child grows older.

The Benefits of a Memory Foam Crib Mattress

A memory foam crib mattress is often the absolute best choice for several reasons. First, it is lightweight, which makes changing sheets – which you will likely do quite often – much, much simpler. What’s more, memory foam crib mattresses are often very firm at the same time, so you do not have to sacrifice firmness for convenience. Finally, experts recommend that parents swap out innerspring mattresses for foam mattresses at about the time a baby begins to pull to a stand. An innerspring mattress can act as a trampoline and cause some safety concerns for your little one. To ease your budget, it is best to choose memory foam from the start.

We have carefully selected the two very best memory foam Crib Mattresses for you to choose from below:

#1 – Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer® Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

#2 – My First Mattress Mattress Premium Memory Foam Crib Mattress

Crib Mattress Reviews 2020

When shopping for the best baby crib mattress, it is important to pay close attention to consumer reviews. These can tell you a lot about a product, and because the opinions are generally unbiased, you can learn more from baby crib mattress reviews than from the manufacturers themselves. Using this approach it is easy to find top-of-the-line products from which you can choose to suit your family’s individual needs. If you are concerned with the use of all-natural products, be sure to look for organic crib mattress reviews.

Sifting through review after review after review can be hard work though, that’s why we have done the work for you. Below are the best-rated crib mattresses currently available on the market, including popular brands such as Sealy, Simmons, Dream on me, Kolcraft, Safety 1st & Naturepedic. Take a look at each brand and their individual offerings, we guarantee one of these mattresses will be perfect for you and your little one.

Naturepedic Crib Mattresses

naturepedic organic crib mattresses

Naturepedic crib mattress reviews are generally positive in nature. Rather than utilizing polyurethane and other materials, the company manufactures their mattresses from layers of organic cotton. The most popular Naturepedic organic crib mattress is the Lightweight Organic Cotton Classic model. It offers two-stage dual firmness, which is perfectly suited for babies and toddlers alike. What’s more, it only weighs between 10 and 12 pounds, making sheet changes a snap. The price fits most budgets, as well, making it the best organic crib mattress for the money.

If you are looking for the best Naturepedic mattress then check out these two, both scoring highly in our analysis:

#1 – Naturepedic No Compromise Organic reviewnaturepedic crib mattress

  • Waterproof surface easy to clean 100% polyethylene food grade waterproof surface.
  • 100% organic cotton, natural and renewable.
  • Hypoallergenic / dust mite barrier cover.
  • Heavy-duty border rods add strong side and edge support.

#2 – Naturepedic Organic Cotton 2-in-1 Ultra review

  • Dual firmness design: top – firmer waterproof side for infants, bottom – softer quilted “Grown Up” style for toddlers.
  • Organic cotton filling: Naturepedic uses only 100% organic cotton to promote a healthy and more chemical-free sleeping environment; organic cotton is unbleached, undyed, and grown without synthetic pesticides, herbicides, or chemical fertilizers.
  • Hypoallergenic: free of wool or latex – no need to worry about these potentially high allergy materials.
  • Firm Support: heavy-duty 252 coils orthopedic innerspring and firm flat surface provide ideal support in accordance with pediatrician and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) firmness recommendations.

Visit Retailer

Simmons Crib Mattresses

Simmons offers two very popular crib mattress options, and each comes with its own inherent set of benefits.

#1 – Simmons Beautyrest Crib Mattress reviewSimmons Kids Beauty Sleep Green Meadows 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

This innerspring mattress features 231 individual coils wrapped in high-quality foam and a dual-sided design. The firm side provides optimal support for newborns and infants, and the memory foam side offers the comfort and coolness toddlers need. What’s more, this particular model has an innovative cover that is both waterproof and antibacterial.

Check Price

#2 – Simmons ComforPedic Crib Mattress review

Unlike the Beautyrest product line, the Simmons ComforPedic crib mattress features a solid foam core. It also has unique infant and toddler sides to provide just the right amount of firmness and comfort as your little one grows. Simmons incorporates a fireproof wrap made of natural cotton and a waterproof, hypo-allergenic vinyl cover.

Check Price

Safety 1st Crib Mattress reviewSafety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams crib mattress boasts a high-density, thermo-bonded core that provides the optimal firmness for your newborn. The mattress is free from lead and phthalates, and it comes with a water-resistant vinyl cover that resists everyday wear and tear. It is one of the most inexpensive baby crib mattresses available, and it boasts Greenguard Gold certification. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams white crib mattress is a very popular choice among parents.

Check Price

Dream On Me Crib Mattresses review

Dream On Me manufactures a number of standard and portable crib mattresses from which you can choose. One of their most popular products is the 3” Dream On Me portable crib mattress, which is perfect for travel. It easily wipes clean with nothing more than mild soap and water, and it features a hypo-allergenic, waterproof, antibacterial cover to set your mind at ease. In fact, it is one of the firmest portable crib mattresses on the market today.

The company also manufactures standard sized baby crib mattresses, including 5” and 6” innerspring models, orthopedic foam models, and innerspring/foam combinations designed to carry your baby from infancy through toddlerhood.

Visit Retailer

Sealy Crib Mattresses

Sealy is one of the world’s most popular mattress manufacturers, and they offer several options for newborns, infants, sealy crib mattressesand toddlers.

#1 – Sealy Soybean Foam-Core review

A popular option among parents who prefer all-natural materials, the soybean foam core offers a firm, yet comfortable sleeping surface. It boasts an airflow pocket on the side to keep the mattress clean and fresh, and its squared-off corners provide a super snug fit into your standard-sized crib.

Check Price

#2 – Sealy Natural Rest review

This mattress features 204 durable innerspring coils and firm hypoallergenic cushioning. It offers plenty of firmness for infants, yet the steel border rods help the edges of the mattress hold up as your toddler grows. It has a waterproof cover that resists stains, moisture, and mildew.

Check Price

#3 – Sealy Perfect Rest review

The Perfect Rest crib mattress from Sealy boasts 150 innerspring coils and steel border rods, which means it grows right along with your baby into toddlerhood. It comes with a tear-proof vinyl cover that resists stains, and it is also hypo-allergenic.

Check Price

#4 – Sealy Posturepedic review

This is the only Sealy crib mattress that offers a hospital-grade waterproof cover over 220 patented Posturetech coils. The mattress actually senses your baby’s movement and responds accordingly. The firm, yet comfortable sleeping surface is perfect for kids of all ages, and it fits standard cribs and toddler beds. The workmanship and materials are backed by a lifetime warranty.

Check Price

Kolcraft Crib Mattresses

The Kolcraft Baby Dri crib mattress is another inexpensive purchase that features 80 interwoven innersprings for firm support and durability. It comes wrapped in a thick hypoallergenic cover that provides a barrier against liquids, and it is easily cleaned with nothing more than mild soap and water. The natural airflow pocket helps keep the mattress fresh and odor-free without the need for metal vents, and despite the low price, it also features a 10-year warranty on workmanship and materials directly from the manufacturer.

Visit Retailer

As you can see, the possibilities are endless when it comes to choosing a baby crib mattress. The two most important features are firmness and fit, but you can find several mattresses that are designed to grow right along with your baby and last you for years to come.

Do You Need a Crib Mattress Cover?

Any time you purchase a memory foam mattress for a baby or child, it is a great idea to also purchase a crib mattress cover to protect it, otherwise known as crib mattress pads. Memory foam is very porous and lightweight; these features provide the comfort and proper sleeping posture. Unfortunately, the same features can lead to a mess if a cover is not used. Look for a zippered crib mattress cover that fits snugly over the mattress, and make sure that the zipper is at the bottom or the side of the mattress when installing in the crib. For the absolute best results, find a cover that is completely waterproof and hypo-allergenic, as this will serve your baby well for a very long time to come.

Visit Retailer & shop crib mattress pads!

What about a Memory Foam Crib Mattress Topper?

Many retailers sell memory foam crib mattress toppers, but the truth is that it is much safer to simply purchase a 6” thick memory foam mattress. Even the best crib mattress pad is usually quite thin – up to 2” – and can sometimes pose safety risks when added to a standard crib mattress. However, if you travel frequently and use a portable crib, you can find thicker and firmer memory foam crib mattress toppers to suit your needs and provide your baby with comfort.

Visit Retailer & shop crib mattress toppers!